Purpose and Scope
This document defines the Engineering Correction Program (ECP) for the Omni-Compass GitHub repository. It establishes the criteria, procedures, checkpoints, and sign-off requirements for independent A-level technical reviewers engaged to audit the codebase, benchmark methodology, mathematical framework, and live data pipeline.
The program is designed to produce a signed, reproducible, and publicly attributable review record. Every finding is classified, tracked, and resolved before the repository is presented to licensees and evaluators.
A-level review means the reviewer operates independently of The Omni-Compass LLC, has no financial interest in the outcome, and applies the standards of a senior engineering peer review — not a commercial due-diligence checklist.
Repository Under Review
REPOSITORY DETAILS
LIVE DATA ENDPOINTS
OMNI_INDEX
ABC_TABLE
SEAL
Reviewer Qualifications
Engineering independence
No current or prior employment, equity, advisory, or contractual relationship with The Omni-Compass LLC or its principals.
Domain competence
Demonstrated expertise in at least two of: control systems, distributed systems, mathematical optimization, C++ systems programming, or statistical validation.
Peer-review experience
Prior experience as a technical reviewer for a refereed journal, conference, or institutional engineering audit program.
Reproducibility capability
Ability to independently execute the Monte Carlo simulation script and verify output against the published SEAL hash.
Conflict disclosure
Signed conflict-of-interest declaration submitted before review commences. Any undisclosed conflict discovered after sign-off invalidates the review record.
Audit Modules
Mathematical Framework Audit
Review the governing convergence control plane law, convergence proofs, admissibility criterion, closed-circle invariance, and scale-invariance properties.
The governing convergence control plane law is stated in closed mathematical form with no undefined terms.
Convergence proofs are complete, self-contained, and free of circular reasoning.
The admissibility criterion is necessary and sufficient as claimed.
Closed-circle invariance holds under the stated conditions.
Scale-invariance is demonstrated across the claimed range of system scales.
No claim of mathematical property is made without a corresponding proof or derivation in the repository.
Monte Carlo Validation Audit
Independently reproduce the Monte Carlo simulation and verify the published results against the SEAL hash.
The simulation script executes without modification using the published seed (0x7F3A9C2E) and produces identical output.
The SHA-256 hash of the output matches the value in SEAL.json.
Zero false positives in the admissibility gate across all 10,000,000 sampled states.
Zero false negatives in the admissibility gate across all 10,000,000 sampled states.
All six verified properties (basin geometry, closed-circle invariance, scale-invariance, admissibility classification, convergence rate, violation count) match the published values.
The simulation is deterministic: repeated runs with the same seed produce byte-identical output.
Benchmark Methodology Audit
Review the four-arm benchmark design (Web/A/B/C), measurement methodology, statistical analysis, and headline gain computation.
The four-arm design (control arm and three treatment arms) is correctly specified with no confounding variables.
Work_completed, p95_ms, and energy_kwh measurements are collected by instrumentation that is independent of the system under test.
The headline GAIN percentage is computed from ABC_TABLE.json by the formula stated in the benchmark methodology document.
Per-category gains (service, ARM-B, ARM-C latency, throughput-cloud) are computed consistently with the headline formula.
No cherry-picking: all arms and all measurement windows are included in the published table.
The benchmark can be reproduced by an independent operator following the published methodology without guidance from the authors.
Live Data Pipeline Audit
Verify the integrity of the live data pipeline from GitHub raw endpoints to the website display.
OMNI_INDEX.json, ABC_TABLE.json, and SEAL.json are fetched directly from the public GitHub repository with no intermediate transformation layer.
The useLiveData() hook computes derived values (wholeSystemGain, muscles/nodes, per-category gains) by deterministic formula from the raw endpoint data.
No hardcoded benchmark numbers appear in the website source code for values that are live-fetched (gain percentages, muscles/nodes count, version).
Fixed catalogue facts (domain count: 9, parity modules: 63, Monte Carlo iterations: 10M+, admissibility/convergence rates: 100%, violation count: 0) are correctly identified as static and not falsely presented as live-measured.
The SEAL hash displayed on the website matches the value in SEAL.json at the time of display.
The pipeline fails gracefully: loading states are shown and no stale or fabricated values are displayed when the endpoint is unreachable.
C++ Codebase Audit
Review the C++ implementation for correctness, safety, and correspondence with the mathematical framework.
The C++ implementation corresponds to the mathematical framework: every equation in the framework has a traceable implementation.
No undefined behavior in the critical path (admissibility gate, convergence loop, state update).
Memory management is correct: no leaks, no use-after-free, no double-free in the governing engine.
Numerical precision is appropriate for the claimed accuracy: floating-point operations do not introduce errors that invalidate the convergence or admissibility results.
The 63 parity modules are present, correctly named, and each corresponds to a documented domain or subsystem.
Build instructions are complete and the codebase compiles without modification on a clean environment.
Claims Correspondence Audit
Verify that every public claim made on the website and in the repository README is supported by evidence in the repository.
Every benchmark number displayed on the website is traceable to a specific field in OMNI_INDEX.json or ABC_TABLE.json.
No claim of a demonstrated advantage is made for a property that is only proposed or hypothetical.
Hypothetical projections (Omni-AI, OCPU) are clearly distinguished from measured results throughout the repository and website.
The IP notice accurately describes the scope of filed intellectual property.
The competitive distinction document does not make false or misleading comparisons to named third-party systems.
The peer review page accurately represents the review status: no claim of completed peer review is made for work that has not been reviewed.
Finding Classification
Critical
A finding that invalidates a core claim, demonstrates mathematical error, or constitutes misrepresentation. Blocks sign-off. Must be resolved before any external distribution.
Major
A finding that weakens a claim, introduces ambiguity in the methodology, or reveals an implementation gap. Blocks sign-off unless the reviewer accepts a documented remediation plan with a fixed deadline.
Minor
A finding that does not affect the validity of any claim but represents an improvement to clarity, documentation, or code quality. Does not block sign-off. Must be logged and addressed in the next revision.
Observation
A note that does not constitute a defect. Included for completeness. No remediation required.
Verification Checkpoints
Reviewer clones the repository at the commit SHA specified in the review engagement letter.
Reviewer verifies the commit SHA against the value in SEAL.json.
Reviewer confirms all three live data endpoints are reachable and returns valid JSON.
Reviewer signs the conflict-of-interest declaration and submits to The Omni-Compass LLC.
Reviewer works through M1 criteria in order, recording a pass/fail/finding for each.
Any CR or MA finding triggers an immediate written notice to The Omni-Compass LLC before proceeding.
Reviewer documents the mathematical review in the standard finding log template.
Reviewer executes: python scripts/monte_carlo.py --seed 0x7F3A9C2E --iterations 10000000
Reviewer computes SHA-256 of the output file and compares to SEAL.json.
Reviewer records the exact machine specification, OS, Python version, and execution time.
Reviewer runs the simulation a second time and confirms byte-identical output (determinism check).
Reviewer downloads ABC_TABLE.json and OMNI_INDEX.json directly from the GitHub raw endpoint.
Reviewer recomputes the headline GAIN from ABC_TABLE.json using the formula in the benchmark methodology document and confirms it matches OMNI_INDEX.json.
Reviewer inspects useLiveData.ts and confirms the derivation formula matches the benchmark methodology.
Reviewer searches the website source for hardcoded benchmark values and confirms none exist for live-fetched fields.
Reviewer builds the C++ codebase on a clean environment using the published build instructions.
Reviewer traces each equation in the mathematical framework to its C++ implementation.
Reviewer works through M6 criteria, verifying each public claim against repository evidence.
Reviewer confirms hypothetical projections are clearly distinguished from measured results in all public-facing materials.
Reviewer compiles the finding log: module, criterion ID, classification (CR/MA/MI/OB), description, evidence, and recommended remediation.
Reviewer submits the draft report to The Omni-Compass LLC for factual accuracy check (not for editorial revision).
The Omni-Compass LLC may correct factual errors (wrong file names, wrong commit SHA) within 5 business days. No substantive findings may be removed or reclassified by the company.
Reviewer issues the final report incorporating any accepted factual corrections.
Sign-Off Procedure
No CR findings open
All Critical findings must be resolved and the resolution verified by the reviewer before sign-off.
MA findings resolved or accepted
All Major findings must be either resolved and verified, or accepted with a documented remediation plan signed by both parties.
MI and OB findings logged
All Minor findings and Observations must appear in the final report. No resolution required for sign-off, but each must have an acknowledged owner and target revision.
Reproducibility confirmed
The Monte Carlo simulation must have been independently executed and the SEAL hash verified before sign-off.
Reviewer identity disclosed
The reviewer's full name, institutional affiliation, and qualifications must appear in the signed report. Anonymous reviews are not accepted under this program.
REVIEWER CERTIFICATION STATEMENT
"I, the undersigned, certify that I have conducted an independent A-level engineering review of the Omni-Compass GitHub repository at the commit SHA specified herein, in accordance with the Engineering Correction Program document version stated above. My findings are recorded in the attached finding log. I have no undisclosed conflicts of interest. This review was conducted independently and my conclusions are my own."
REQUIRED SIGN-OFF FIELDS
Reviewer full name
Institutional affiliation
Review engagement date
Repository commit SHA reviewed
SEAL.json hash at time of review
Finding summary (CR / MA / MI / OB counts)
Sign-off date
Reviewer signature
Document Revision History
| Version | Date | Author | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | 2026-10-26 | The Omni-Compass LLC | Initial issue. |
Interested in conducting an independent review?
Contact The Omni-Compass LLC to discuss reviewer engagement, access to the repository, and the review timeline. All qualified reviewers are welcome.
EXTERNAL REFERENCES